Volume 1,Issue 2
Evaluating the Effectiveness of Government Emergency Response: A Characteristic-Based Framework, Tested against Major Accident Investigation Reports since 2010
Emergency response is a critical element of government emergency management. A successful response typically exhibits four characteristic features: timeliness, accuracy, regularity and systematicity. These four features can serve as the basis for constructing a theoretical framework for evaluating the effectiveness of government emergency response. The investigation reports on major accident and disaster response published by the Ministry of Emergency Management since 2010 also show that when all four features are satisfied simultaneously, the government response is efficient. Inefficient responses, by contrast, exhibit marked deficiencies in one or more of these four features. According to this characteristic-based evaluation framework, there are four important current pathways for enhancing government emergency response capacity: improving intelligence gathering and decision-making capacity; scientifically assessing the causes of events and respecting the laws governing their development; optimising the regulatory system and strengthening control over its implementation; and reinforcing systemic thinking and a sense of the overall picture.